Penny Hendrie

Senior CL Insurance Advisor | Commercial, Personal & Life Insurance Specialist

Proudly protecting our communities with modern service, local care, expert advice, and coverage that fits.

Picture of Penny Hendrie

Penny Hendrie is a Senior Insurance Advisor at Eastern Insuring Agency, bringing more than 32 years of insurance experience helping individuals, families, and business owners protect what matters most.

Having built her career through the respected LaBarge Agency before joining Eastern Insuring Agency, Penny has become a trusted resource for clients throughout Plattsburgh, the North Country, and communities across New York State. Her extensive experience spans commercial insurance, personal insurance, life insurance, homeowners insurance, auto insurance, umbrella coverage, recreational vehicle insurance, and risk management planning.

Penny believes that great insurance advice starts with listening. Throughout her career, she has built long-lasting relationships by taking the time to understand her clients' goals, concerns, and unique circumstances before recommending coverage solutions. Whether helping a business owner protect their operations, a family insure their home and vehicles, or an individual plan for their financial future through life insurance, Penny focuses on providing guidance that is clear, personalized, and easy to understand.

Known for her exceptional customer service and attention to detail, Penny works closely with clients to review policies, identify coverage gaps, and recommend changes that align with their evolving needs. Her educational approach empowers clients to make informed insurance decisions and feel confident in their protection strategy.

Clients appreciate Penny's ability to simplify complex insurance topics while remaining accessible, responsive, and genuinely invested in their success. Many of the relationships she has developed over the years have spanned decades, reflecting the trust and confidence she has earned throughout her career.

Outside of the office, Penny enjoys exploring the outdoors and discovering new hiking trails throughout the Adirondacks and Northern New York. She often shares her favorite outdoor adventures and local discoveries with friends, family, and clients, further strengthening the community connections that have always been at the heart of her work.

Whether you're protecting your business, home, vehicles, recreational assets, or loved ones, Penny is committed to helping you find the right coverage and providing the personalized service you deserve.

Specialized in

check
Commercial Insurance
check
Personal Insurance, Including Life
check
Pizzerias, Small Restaurants, Florists & Liquor Stores

Why Work With Me?

check
32+ Years of Experience
check
Long-Term Client Relationships
check
Personalized Coverage Reviews

Let’s Make Sure Your Coverage is Working for You

Orange icon of a document with a checklist and a magnifying glass over it.

Real - WorldRisk ANALYSIS

Identifying the exposures your industry faces.No generic forms.

Icon of two stacked documents with user profile symbols and horizontal lines representing text.

Contract + Compliance Review

Spotting coverage gaps other brokers overlook before you sign.

protection

Proactive Carrier Management

Placing, monitoring + adjusting coverage as your needs change.

Orange line art of a laptop and smartphone with a Wi-Fi symbol on the phone screen.

Local Service + Online Help

Hands-on support plus online tools for managing certificates, claims, and documents

Site Logo
An independent insurance agency providing personal, commercial, and life insurance solutions across New York.
phone

1-800-698-1222  
Call or Text

Quick Links

Get a Smarter QuoteClient Service CenterPersonal InsuranceBusiness InsuranceResourcesContact Us

Resources

CarriersCommunity InvolvementPrivacy PolicyTerms of UseAccessibilitySitemap

Our Locations

maps-and-flags

Amsterdam

2 Guy Park Avenue
Amsterdam, NY 12010
maps-and-flags

Carmel

72 Gleneida Avenue
Carmel, NY 10510
maps-and-flags

Malone

7 Rockland Street, Suite A
Malone, NY 12953
maps-and-flags

Plattsburgh

1645 Military Turnpike Hwy
Plattsburgh, NY 12901
Email

Stay Informed

Helpful insurance tips, agency updates and more -straight to your inbox.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Eastern Insuring Agency is licensed to provide insurance services in New York State. Coverage is subject to underwriting guidelines and policy terms.
© 2026 Eastern Insuring Agency. All rights reserved.
Trusted Choice independent insurance agent logo with a stylized bird and text.Big I Insurance Agents logo with stylized letter I in a circle.NYIA New York Independent Agents logo with flame icon.