Debra "Debbie" Cosentino

Debra "Debbie" Cosentino brings more than three decades of insurance experience to Eastern Insuring Agency and the Putman Agency team in Amsterdam, New York. Known for her exceptional attention to detail, genuine compassion, and unwavering commitment to client service, Debbie has built a career centered around helping individuals, families, and business owners protect what matters most.

Since beginning her insurance career in 1990, Debbie has developed extensive knowledge across multiple areas of insurance, including medical insurance, personal insurance, and property and casualty coverage. Her broad industry experience, combined with her dedication to continuous learning, allows her to help clients navigate insurance decisions with confidence and clarity.

Throughout her career, Debbie has earned a reputation as someone who truly cares about the people she serves. She believes insurance is more than policies and coverage forms—it's about helping clients prepare for life's unexpected moments and ensuring they have the protection they need when it matters most. Whether assisting with policy reviews, answering questions, updating coverage, or helping clients through challenging situations, Debbie approaches every interaction with patience, professionalism, and a genuine desire to help.

Clients appreciate Debbie's ability to listen carefully, explain coverage options clearly, and provide thoughtful recommendations tailored to their unique circumstances. Her attention to detail and commitment to excellence help ensure that clients receive personalized service and coverage solutions designed to meet their needs both today and in the future.

As a valued member of Eastern Insuring Agency and the Putman Agency team, Debbie is proud to continue building long-term relationships based on trust, integrity, and exceptional service. Her caring approach and dedication to doing what's right for clients have made her a trusted advisor to many individuals and families throughout the Amsterdam community and beyond.

Outside of the office, Debbie enjoys spending time with family and friends, attending live music events, cheering on the Pittsburgh Steelers and New York Yankees, supporting the Amsterdam Mohawks, bowling, gardening, and caring for her beloved black cat. Her enthusiasm for life and strong connection to her community are reflected in the same warmth and positivity she brings to every client relationship.

Whether you're reviewing your insurance coverage, protecting your home and vehicles, or planning for the future, Debbie is committed to providing the guidance, support, and personalized attention you deserve.